Specialized academic councils evaluate such research very rigorously. The work must meet the following key criteria:
- Significant scientific contribution. The research must address a truly important problem. The solution should provide tangible benefits – economic, social, or technological.
- Field-level novelty. The results must be entirely original. It is not sufficient to slightly improve existing theories; it is necessary to develop a new paradigm or a unique methodology.
- Depth and scope of research. The problem must be analyzed comprehensively. It is necessary to cover related areas and rely on a substantial body of verified data.
- Validity of results. All conclusions must be clearly substantiated. This involves the use of modern research methods, advanced mathematical modeling, and large-scale experiments.
- Theoretical or applied results. The work must include both profound theoretical insights and practical recommendations that can be implemented.